ReLope: From Hidden-State Probing to a Decision Module for Multimodal LLM Routing

Routing balances performance and cost in hybrid systems by escalating selected queries from a lightweight model to a powerful but expensive one. Hidden-state probes provide an effective routing signal by predicting the small model's correctness from hidden states it already computes. Although effective in text-only settings, their behavior on multimodal LLMs (MLLMs) is less understood. We find that correctness is harder to predict from hidden states when questions are paired with images rather than with captions of those images. Two training-free dependence measures, HSIC and label CKA, show the same pattern. We first investigate whether changing hidden states used by the probe improves correctness prediction for MLLMs. We propose Attention Probe, which learns an attention query to pool frozen token states into a routing feature and improves over the standard probe. However, pooling only recombines hidden states computed for answer generation, not for deciding whether the answer should be trusted. We therefore build a decision layer inside the existing MLLM and train it for the routing decision. The resulting router, ReLope (KL-Regularized LoRA Probe), adapts a separate copy of one MLLM layer with LoRA and regularizes it with a KL-penalized stochastic bottleneck. This decision branch shares the frozen lower layers and leaves the model's answer-generation path unchanged. ReLope attains the highest correctness prediction AUC on all five benchmarks and three backbones we evaluate and improves the accuracy versus cost trade-off at negligible overhead. These results suggest a new perspective and a practical technical path on routing: rather than reading decisions off states built for generation, routing decisions can be learned by a dedicated decision layer inside the model. Code: https://github.com/Spinozaaa/ReLope